Some like it hot: spicy drinks will have you feeling toasty

Hot pumpkin toddy. Hot buttered rum. Spiced latte. Mulled wine. Are you feeling toasty already? It’s the season for warming up inside with hot drinks, and bars are already offering some fine ones on the menu. But they’re just as easy to make at home — and that way you don’t even have to de-ice the car.

“In a colder climate, it’s a little more comforting to have something warm in your hand, “says Rodel Borromeo, executive chef at Social Bar and Grill on the waterfront in Tacoma, Wash., where the drinks menu has just moved on from hot pumpkin toddies to hot buttered rums.

“(Our) hot buttered rum is moving pretty well.”

Hot alcoholic drinks go back a long way, of course: Hot toddies crop up in Charles Dickens and Jack London; hot negus (mulled wine) in Jane Austen. The hot toddy, made of sugar, spice, citrus, alcohol and hot water, is a traditional way to cure a cold — or at least, cheer yourself up while you’re suffering. Hot buttered rum, with its mixture of creamed butter and sugar, spices, rum and hot water, is also soothing. And there’s something about frothy milk or cream that will warm up anyone.

But drinks chefs in Tacoma and Olympia, Wash., have ways of spicing up the traditional recipes that will make them burn even brighter. “We add a bit of cayenne to give a bit more warmth to the experience, “ says Borromeo, of Social’s hot buttered rum recipe, where the recipe also calls for a little bit of Bailey’s Irish Cream to cream out the drink. Cayenne also spices up hot milk drinks such as cocoa, chai or coffee lattes.

Or you could try a different spice mix. Buck’s 5th Avenue Spices in Olympia has a chutney mix of ground cardamom, cinnamon, ginger and black pepper that their drinks expert, Brooke Ahnemann, likes to sprinkle on hot cocoa or coffee. Other options include dusting a creamy milk drink with bittersweet chocolate powder, and Ahnemann likes a latte sprinkled with a bit of Bucks’ espresso-flavored salt.

Not into milk? Try wine. Mulling wine goes back centuries, with many names around Europe: think Nordic Glogg, or German Gluhwein. You can buy mulling wine spices from stores such as Buck’s, but putting your own mix together is also easy: The usual ingredients are whole cloves, cinnamon sticks, whole allspice and a bit of orange peel. Wrap in a cheesecloth bag or just float them in the wine and scoop them out when you’re done. Boil the wine with sugar to taste.

But how much spice? “Everyone has different tastes,” Ahnemann says. “I usually recommend people start with a tablespoon of spice mix per bottle of wine and add more if they like it.”
Another way to get extra flavor is to add a sweet liqueur such as Triple Sec instead of sugar, Ahnemann suggests.

Need something nonalcoholic? You can mull cider, too. Ahnemann uses the Buck’s combination of spices, plus some lemon peel and dried rosebuds for floral fragrance. Or try making hot buttered rum without the rum, adding cream soda instead — you’ll get something rather like Harry Potter’s butterbeer, sweet and rich.

Then there’s toddy. The story goes that this sweet, lemony alcoholic drink was brought to England by someone in the East India trading company from India, where people still make strong, distilled toddy from palm tree sap. Hot toddy’s easy enough to make — just mix a little sugar or honey, a little spice (cinnamon, or cloves), a dash of lemon juice and a shot of whisky or rum with some hot water.

But if you want to make it a little different, try Borromeo’s version, which just went off the seasonal menu at Social: roasted pumpkin, mashed into a puree with honey and simple syrup. Being a puree, it’ll separate if you leave it sitting, says Borromeo, so just stir if necessary.

Finally, there’s the froth. Not all hot drinks need it — you won’t be wanting to froth mulled wine or cider — but it’s useful if you’re sprinkling spices or chocolate. The easiest way is by adding whipped cream: Marcie Triner-Anderson, head bartender at Varsity Grill, uses this to top off her popular coffee-chocolate blend spiked with peppermint schnapps and creamed vodka.

Or you can whip your own milk or cream with a handheld electric mixer, an espresso steamer or a whisk. For a party trick, and to cool down a piping hot drink, try what chai sellers in India do: Pour a latte from one cup into another and back again, increasing the distance until you have a froth. (This might be something to practice over the sink first.)

We may have a long, cold winter ahead of us — but think of it as a deliciously long time to whip up your own menu of hot, frothy drinks. You might even cure a cold or two as well.

GINGERBREAD LATTE
—
Yield: 1 serving

2 ounces prepared coffee or espresso
2 tablespoons gingerbread-flavored syrup
1/2 cup milk, steamed
1/8 cup frothed milk
1 pinch pumpkin pie spice
1/2 teaspoon vanilla powder

Procedure:
1. In coffee mug, combine coffee or espresso with flavored syrup.
2. Pour in steamed milk and frothed milk and sprinkle with pumpkin pie spice and vanilla powder.

WINTER NIGHTCAP
—
Yield: 4 servings

1 shot coffee liqueur
1 shot Irish cream liqueur
1 1/2 shots hazelnut liqueur
4 cups hot coffee
Cream

Procedure:
1. Mix coffee and liqueurs.
2. Serve with cream.

MARCIE’S SPECIAL
—
Yield: 1 serving

1/2 ounce Rumple Minze or other peppermint schnapps
1/2 ounce Pinnacle brand Whipped Vodka
Black coffee
Hot chocolate
Whipped cream
Chocolate sprinkles

Procedure:
1. Mix schnapps and vodka with equal parts black coffee and hot chocolate.
2. Garnish with whipped cream and chocolate sprinkles.

Varsity Grill, Tacoma, Wash.

MULLED WINE or CIDER
—
Yield: About 6 servings

Whole cloves
Allspice
Cinnamon
Orange peel
Lemon peel (optional)
1 (750 ml) bottle wine or 3-4 cups apple cider
Sugar or a sweet liqueur such as Triple Sec Bourbon (optional)

Procedure:
1. Combine cloves, allspice, cinnamon, orange peel and lemon peel.
2. Boil 1 bottle wine with 1 tablespoon spice mix. Add sugar or sweet liqueur to taste. Add more spice mix to taste.
3. Optional: If mulling nonalcoholic cider, add bourbon to glass, if desired.

Bucks Fifth Avenue spice store, Olympia, Wash.

HOT BUTTERED RUM
—
Yield: Mix for several drinks

1/4 pound butter, at room temperature
1/2 pound light brown sugar
1 teaspoon each ground cinnamon and whole cloves
1/2 teaspoon each ground nutmeg, cayenne pepper and salt
Spiced rum of choice
Bailey’s Irish Cream
Whole cinnamon sticks, for garnish

Procedure:
1. Mix together butter, brown sugar, spices and salt (store in refrigerator if not using all at once).
2. Per drink: Add 1 tablespoon mix to 4 ounces hot water. Let melt. Add 2-3 ounces spiced rum and a dash of Baileys Irish Cream; float a cinnamon stick as garnish.

Social Bar and Grill, Tacoma, Wash.

HOT PUMPKIN TODDY
—
Yield: 1 serving

Roasted pumpkin
Simple syrup
Honey
Hot water
Whiskey
Cinnamon stick (optional)
Chili powder (optional)

Procedure:
1. Puree equal parts roasted pumpkin, simple syrup and honey.
2. Mix 2 ounces pumpkin puree with 4 ounces hot water. Add 1 1/2 shots whiskey.
3. Add cinnamon stick and dash of chili powder, if desired. (This will separate after sitting, so it needs stirring.)

Social Bar and Grill, Tacoma, Wash.